UPSB v3
News & Announcements / Betamoderator Evaluation For strat1227
Your chance to evaluate the staff!
-
Date: Wed, May 5 2010 21:33:45
It's one month already since strat1227 has been promoted, so it is time for him to pass the public evaluation.
Please no flaming, post comments / feedback if you wish so.
Remember that while the results of the poll are of great importance, the rest of the moderating staff have the final say on the decision. -
Date: Wed, May 5 2010 22:17:01
retain.
I like red better.
but nah nah,
make mod. -
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 00:10:13
Lol i hope these are all joke retains, I'm only at 60% approval right now ...
Please don't do any more joke retains guys -
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 06:39:43
Quick question: how much actions or w/e they're called has strat done as a Beta-mod?
-
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 12:35:54
71
-
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 15:58:50
strats awesome....he answers my questions...and hes funny on the sb...
-
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 20:07:17
good luck strat i =]
-
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 23:10:40
YAY STRAT!!!!
-
Date: Thu, May 6 2010 23:32:47
Retain. I really mean no personal offense to you at all, and I think you'd be a great moderator, but I just don't really see the reason for you becoming a mod. I mean, the past few mods were made because they had a specific purpose to respond to the growing community, shoutbox, and watching over the trade section, but your promotion was rather.....random =\ There's no reason at all to not make you mod, because you are indeed a great candidate, but there's also no real reason to grant you full moderator status either, since the community isn't in any need of a new mod. IMO, I prefer that people would become mod for a specific purpose, rather than the sake of becoming a general mod, but, that's just me. I think you'd be better off being head of the research department hehe. Nothing really against you, I just think that if UPSB actually needs a new mod, then you'll be the one, but, as of now, I think it should be kept as it was before your promotion.
-
Date: Fri, May 7 2010 00:02:18QUOTE (Loanshark @ May 6 2010, 07:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>Retain. I really mean no personal offense to you at all, and I think you'd be a great moderator, but I just don't really see the reason for you becoming a mod. I mean, the past few mods were made because they had a specific purpose to respond to the growing community, shoutbox, and watching over the trade section, but your promotion was rather.....random =\ There's no reason at all to not make you mod, because you are indeed a great candidate, but there's also no real reason to grant you full moderator status either, since the community isn't in any need of a new mod. IMO, I prefer that people would become mod for a specific purpose, rather than the sake of becoming a general mod, but, that's just me. I think you'd be better off being head of the research department hehe. Nothing really against you, I just think that if UPSB actually needs a new mod, then you'll be the one, but, as of now, I think it should be kept as it was before your promotion.
Its to make up for the dearth of Tialys.
Not to mention, Strat is awesomeness. -
Date: Fri, May 7 2010 07:47:22QUOTE (Loanshark @ May 6 2010, 07:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>Retain. I really mean no personal offense to you at all, and I think you'd be a great moderator, but I just don't really see the reason for you becoming a mod. I mean, the past few mods were made because they had a specific purpose to respond to the growing community, shoutbox, and watching over the trade section, but your promotion was rather.....random =\ There's no reason at all to not make you mod, because you are indeed a great candidate, but there's also no real reason to grant you full moderator status either, since the community isn't in any need of a new mod. IMO, I prefer that people would become mod for a specific purpose, rather than the sake of becoming a general mod, but, that's just me. I think you'd be better off being head of the research department hehe. Nothing really against you, I just think that if UPSB actually needs a new mod, then you'll be the one, but, as of now, I think it should be kept as it was before your promotion.
I disagree. I think we're running a little low on moderating power, and we need more people to mod just everything. I was actually thinking that we might need one more mod on top of strat in the near future... but I couldn't think of an active, qualified person.
I feel like current mods are becoming less active, including myself, and we need someone to fill in that gap. Strat has made many contributions to PS, and he continues to be a strong leader.. and he's very active, at least for now. I'm in favor of his promotion. -
Date: Fri, May 7 2010 08:39:21
I won't vote yet 'cause I'm not sure. I'm really slanting towards him being a mod because of what JC said and strats really active now but I was still wondering whether his current actions are only a means for him to become a moderator (no offence strat) what I mean is like if you are only active and helpful now because he has been a newly added mod. I'm not sure if it'll slow down or you'd wear out from the hard work. By the way Zombo, what are the exact things duties for being a mod. This is not to mock you in anyway, Strat you know I love you!!(not being gay) I ythink you'd do a great job and you really deserve it!!
-
Date: Fri, May 7 2010 16:31:07
i don't know strat that much, but if so many ppl think he should be a moderater, i will take their words for it, go strat!
-
Date: Fri, May 7 2010 20:22:24
Grant. Strat is real kind, awesome and helpful. He'll become a very good moderator.
Good Look Strat!
-
Date: Sat, May 8 2010 02:06:00
Voted for full mod of course. I definitely feel like you deserve to be a mod strat! cool guy, helpful, very well qualified, active, experienced, etc. And the more mods the better imo, when some are becoming a little less active due to life XD
However, red names look cooler. I guess b/c the color of blue for mods is too grayish-blue imo. -
Date: Wed, May 12 2010 11:36:52
i think as there arent much mods and strat is a bit active so he shud bcome a mod and hav full authority.
-
Date: Wed, May 12 2010 15:53:43
the poll results at 61% would make an acceptance the lowest by around 10%.
combined with the high rate of rejection of 10%, highest among accepted mods
strat cannot be made a full mod for now.
He must be re-evaluated in 1 month.
It is not clear the extent of "unserious voters", but please vote seriously next time. -
Date: Wed, May 12 2010 16:23:36
I'm not sure that I understand the reasoning for the high percentage of "retain" votes, beta-mod has all the same powers as a regular mod, and I've certainly done enough modding in the past month for people to know whether they like me as a mod or not, I'm not sure what this next month of evaluation would change
-
Date: Wed, May 12 2010 16:27:36QUOTE (strat1227 @ May 13 2010, 12:23 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>I'm not sure that I understand the reasoning for the high percentage of "retain" votes, beta-mod has all the same powers as a regular mod, and I've certainly done enough modding in the past month for people to know whether they like me as a mod or not, I'm not sure what this next month of evaluation would change
I agree with you. I dunno' why the retain votes should be taken into consideration. Strat has proven he's worth to be a mod already (my opinion) -
Date: Wed, May 12 2010 16:34:45QUOTE (strat1227 @ May 12 2010, 12:23 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>I'm not sure that I understand the reasoning for the high percentage of "retain" votes, beta-mod has all the same powers as a regular mod, and I've certainly done enough modding in the past month for people to know whether they like me as a mod or not, I'm not sure what this next month of evaluation would change
theres great importance placed on this popular opinion, since its pretty much the only opportunity they have to express their opinion. so the results must be convincing. this is not convincing.
the powers are the same, but it's like awarding tenure. -
Date: Wed, May 12 2010 20:33:38
Yeah I didn't disagree with your decision, I just don't understand the logic behind the voting, I've done enough for people to gather an opinion on the job I've done
-
Date: Thu, May 13 2010 00:54:22
like I said, some ppl might have not voted seriously and its not possible to know who did or did not,
maybe next time they'll vote seriously and the results will be conclusive -
Date: Thu, May 13 2010 02:01:38
i think upsb could use a new mod since the previous mods arent really active
and i think this is becoming sort of a cycle.
a new mod comes forth and other mods become less active then a new mod is chosen then some other mods become less active
it seems like its happening... granted, as mods become older, theyre less likely to be active, but im just sayin
all in all, strat would be a good mod. he helps out people a lot on the shoutbox, on the forum in general and whatnot
i accidentally nulled.... -.- my bad -
Date: Thu, May 13 2010 11:53:05QUOTE (SJ @ May 12 2010, 10:01 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>i think upsb could use a new mod since the previous mods arent really active
and i think this is becoming sort of a cycle.
a new mod comes forth and other mods become less active then a new mod is chosen then some other mods become less active
it seems like its happening... granted, as mods become older, theyre less likely to be active, but im just sayin
all in all, strat would be a good mod. he helps out people a lot on the shoutbox, on the forum in general and whatnot
i accidentally nulled.... -.- my bad
can't help it
life gets busier when we grow up lol...
i'm surprised zombo manages to still be so active, and i'm so thankful he is
but sorry i'm becoming inactive and falling into this cycle
as for strat's evaluation, not many people voted overall if you compare it to how many votes the other evaluations got.... that's why the retains/strip votes he did get (joke/not joke) counted for so much more
people seem to care less about evaluation polls now maybe? maybe that's why they're not voting, and the total votes isn't like..double what it is now (should be closer to ~120)
--and then, after all the joke (or even not joke) votes are done being given (cause those people who'd vote that way would vote right away), the rest of the votes that people usually give are mostly all grants
-- dunno why, compared to other evaluations, not as many people voted =\ -
Date: Thu, May 13 2010 16:17:41
o_0
im a bit surprised.....strat is awesome... -
Date: Sun, May 16 2010 05:35:08
ok im actually gonna be serious on this post. the fact that strat didn't get voted is a bit stupid as strat posses most of the aspects that are needed in moderating an internet forum. he can keep seriousness when necessary but is socially accepted amongst the board as one of the common, retaining a sense of connection with the community which is really important. all the "joke votes" are just kinda stupid as even i did not screw with this as it's a one time official thing. strat i wish you all the luck and hope people stop being idiotic.