UPSB v3
Forum Games / Mafia DC - Post Game Thread
Discuss here
-
Date: Mon, Sep 24 2007 19:41:00
GG. Too easy for you guys.
-
Date: Mon, Sep 24 2007 20:09:39
Yay!
You played pretty well too.
Killing eburt did give us quite a lot of information though.
GG -
Date: Mon, Sep 24 2007 20:22:05
Yeah it's a gamble basically. I mean, I could have waited to see everyone else's results the first day, but Eburt and Cybrax know me as a very active player and I felt that would have drawn suspicion. In retrospect I should have killed Cybrax, because he was one of 2 possible real cops, but I thought that the "Why would I kill someone who defended me?" strategy might work. Unforunately for me Cybrax inspected both me and Eburt in a row lol. It was fun, and I should have faked and killed more carefully, but props to you guys. Eburt actually should have known the first day. He knew he was a cop, and there were 3 innocents between us (although one was my lie). That means that one of the cops always got innocent, one was the real cop, and the last innocent was the person getting the wrong answer. Eburt would have been able to tell he was the cop getting the wrong answers, and thus I was mafia. Anyways, it was fun. I hope I get to be mafia in a non DC version if there is ever another mafia game.
-
Date: Mon, Sep 24 2007 20:39:18
I'll try to join the next game too
I have never ever been mafia yet, though I've played this game quite a lot (as a card game too)
the only time I was mafia the dealer dropped the card for the next player, so we had to re-deal the cards
-
Date: Mon, Sep 24 2007 21:43:11
So my first ever guess was right
-
Date: Mon, Sep 24 2007 22:50:26
Believe or not.
I suspected ShortAssassin in the first place because of his name. ASSassIn lol.
It would have been a lot more confusing if he hadnt kill Eburt. -
Date: Tue, Sep 25 2007 01:58:01
Had you killed Cybrax, I woulda come at you harder than a twelve year old on viagra, watching porn for the first time.
Srsly, I was 100 % sure you were guilty after last night. Killing Cybrax only woulda given me one more piece of evidence
Good game though. And yeah, maybe I coulda figured it out on day one (I was Insane btw) but I couldn't of been sure... woulda required jumping the gun a bit. But yeah, great job SA. In my oppinion you played about as well as you could of. Its just that a lot of people inspected you. Had that ben different you might have gotten away with it too, if it weren't for us meddling kids! -
Date: Tue, Sep 25 2007 02:01:24
Yeah, I guess if I killed Cybrax you would have been able to figure it out anyway so I guess it didn't really matter what decision I made lol. I did get kinda unlucky, I figured a lot of people would inspect me and Eburt for some reason.
-
Date: Tue, Sep 25 2007 02:42:41
Results plus other to be discussed here.
Game thread
Edit:
Ok, I was MEANT to split those posts from the game thread into a new topic, then merge it with this one (that 'temporary thread') but I don't seem to have moderating powers to merge, lol.
Edit: and now that Zombo merged them, my post is at the bottom, LOL. -
Date: Tue, Sep 25 2007 02:59:54
GG, I think this game having an open setup and the unique cop dynamic gives it a very different feel and it's not played liek a real game at all. Much more logical deductions can be done.
I think SA made the mistake of killing the same person as his "investigation claim". He should have claimed to investigate somebody else if he wanted to kil eburt in night 1. -
Date: Wed, Sep 26 2007 21:14:53
I fuckin TOLD YOU I knew in my gut it was shortassassin.